The 5 Best Tire Plug Kits to Keep Handy

The 5 Best Tire Plug Kits to Keep Handy

tire plug kit featured image
  • Share On Facebook
  • Share On Twitter
  • Pin it!

It happens to the best of us. You’re driving down the road and your tire goes right over a hidden nail. You might not notice it right away, but after a few days, you begin to notice that tire looks a little flatter than the others. But there's no tire plug kit in the car.

No big deal, you think. You stop at a gas station and put some air in the tire and go on your way.

But a few days later, you notice the same problem.

This time, you give your tire a more thorough inspection, and that’s when you see it. A nail has punctured your tire.

While not the worst thing in the world, this still be a hassle to fix. You don’t want to spend big bucks on a new tire, so your next best bet is to try and plug the leak.

Most repair shops will take care of the problem for you, but you may end up spending more than you hoped. Fortunately, there’s a DIY option that could save you some time and hassle.

We’ve done the research and come up with the ultimate list of the top five tire plug kits that you need to keep handy.


How We Chose Our Ratings


We combed through the internet and researched dozens of different tire plug kits, from professional quality solutions to easy quick-fix options, to find the absolute cream of the crop.

From there, we used a proven combination of important factors to determine the strengths and weaknesses of each product. We then assigned a score to each product out of five possible points, with five being the highest and zero being the lowest. Simply put, products with more strengths than weaknesses ranked higher. Those with more weaknesses or strengths that were less impressive by comparison were ranked lower.

Here are the six main details we considered when compiling our final rankings:

  • Product descriptions of a tire plug kit

We looked over the product descriptions and specifications from the manufacturers of each product, but we did this with a grain of salt. After all, companies are never going to admit that their product is inferior to their competition. They will always be hyping up the features they feel are most beneficial and unique about their product. We considered which products promised the best fix and performed as advertised.

  • Price of a tire plug kit

Budget is always a consideration for users of the product. So, we took into account the price of each product we reviewed. Tire plug kits that appeared to be more of a bargain rated higher, while those that were overpriced in our opinion received a lower rating.

  • Ease of use

What good is a tire plug kit if it’s too difficult or frustrating to use? Our research looked into how easy or it was to operate each product. In addition, we want to see how clear the instructions were for users.

  • Quality of fix

While all products claim to fix the problem, the fact is not that all fixes are equal. Products that seemed to perform better with fixes that held up longer received higher rankings in our system. Those that just temporarily solved the problem or needed to be fixed repeatedly received lower ratings.

  • Brand Reputation

Name recognition is an important factor for consumers. People are more likely to spend their money on brands with which they are familiar. So those products from a well-known brand received a slight bump in our rating system.

  • Customer reviews

The most important factor we considered to determine our final rankings was testimonials and real reviews from actual users. People who spent money on the product are more likely to leave honest and unbiased feedback. We looked into the number of positive reviews compared to negative reviews for specific tire plug kits and individual features about each product that users either loved or hated.


Quick Comparison Table: The 5 Best Tire Plug Kits 


After going through this extensive rating process, we came up with five tire plug kits that we believe overall are the best products on the market today.

It’s worth noting that many of the brands that appear in our list sell a variety of tire plug kits in all shapes and sizes to be used on anything from wheelbarrows to heavy-duty trucks. We tried to stick with products that could be used on everyday vehicles and only selected one tire plug kit per brand to feature in our list.

Here are the top five tire plug kits you should keep handy in case you puncture a tire.


Full Reviews Of The 5 Best Tire Plug Kits to Fix a Leak


1. Boulder Tools 56-Piece Heavy Duty Tire Plug Kit


One of the top selling tire plug kits on the market today, the Boulder Tools 56-Piece Heavy Duty Tire Repair Kit comes in first on our list.

This set includes quality and professional grade tools and pieces that you can use to fix all types of punctures for a variety of vehicles. Boulder claims its parts are stronger and longer lasting than other comparable kits on the market, promising a more secure and safe plug to your leak. Instructions are clearly marked and included within this set, which comes in a heavy-duty plastic carrying case that protects the tools inside yet is small enough that it can easily be stored in your garage or trunk. Plus, Boulder provides a one-year warranty on the tools in its tire repair kit.

The Boulder Tools 56-Piece Heavy Duty Tire Plug Kit received almost unanimous praise from drivers who have used the product. Users were impressed by the quality of pieces included in the kit, performance and ease of use, and overall durability. And as an added bonus, this kit is cheaper than some of the similar products on the market from different brands.

PR​​​​OS

  • Quality
  • Brand recognition
  • Overwhelming customer support

CON​S

  • None

Overall, the Boulder Tools 56-Piece Heavy Duty Tire Plug Kit stands above the rest in terms of DIY emergency repair options for your punctured tires.

QUALITY

PRICE

OUR RATING

$$

2. Slime Safety Spair Tire Repair Kit


Don’t let the name fool you, there’s nothing to be grossed out by with the Slime Safety Spair Repair Kit.

This product not only helps seals a puncture but also allows you to refill the air in your tire at the same time. The kit comes in a zippered case, helping to keep all the essential pieces together and can easily be stored in the trunk of your car. The company claims that this product will help you plug and refill your punctured tire in less than 10 minutes, getting you back on the road faster. Like most of the tire plug kits on our list, this product is only intended for emergency repairs, however, Slime claims you will be able to drive for up to 500 miles after patching your tire with their product.

PR​​​​OS

  • Fixes puncture and inflate tires in less than 10 minutes
  • Ease of use
  • Adaptable to various size tires and vehicles

CONS

  • Price

Customer reviews for the Slime Safety Spare Tire Repair Kit are overwhelmingly positive. Drivers raved about the ease of use and versatility. Users also remarked how the product performed as advertised, assuming you follow the directions. If there is a drawback to the Slime Safety Spare Tire Repair Kit, it’s the price. Compared to some of the other kits on our list, this product is one of the more expensive tire plug kits.

QUALITY

PRICE

OUR RATING

$$

3. Blackjack KT-340


Rounding out the top three tire plug kits is the Blackjack KT-340.

What’s unique about this product is that Blackjack claims its kit can perform permanent tire repairs, similar to the quality that you’d receive if you took your vehicle to a repair shop – but for a fraction of the cost. The product claims to have superior performance, durability, and ease of use thanks to its T-BONE handle. The instruction manual is easy to read and includes large colorful pictures that clearly show step-by-step how the plug needs to be performed.

While the company raves about the quality of its handle, users had a mixed reaction. Some thought it provided the extra comfort and strength to seal their punctures, while others said it was poorly manufactured and actually made the repairs more difficult. It seems it comes down to personal preference.

PR​​​​OS

  • Permanent plug if performed correctly
  • Price 
  • Clear and easy to read instructions

CONS

  • Poor website
  • Complaints about handle quality

Another one of the main drawbacks to this product was the quality of the website, which could reflect negatively on the brand for users who are still shopping around.

QUALITY

PRICE

OUR RATING

$$

4. BETOOLL 67-Piece Tire Repair Kit


Another multi-piece tire plug kit comes in at fourth on our list.

At first glance, the BETOOLL 67-Piece Tire Repair Kit looks very similar to the two products ranked immediately above it. This kit includes multiple pieces that can be used to plug leaks in tires in a variety of sizes. Instructions are clearly printed and included in the heavy-duty plastic carrying case. Plus, this product easily stores in your home, workshop, or vehicle. One of the main advantages of this kit is that BETOOLL will offer a full refund if a customer is not satisfied with the product.

One of the big drawbacks of this kit is the organization of those pieces within the case. While other kits have dedicated spots for the dozens of pieces, BETOOLL’s model is a little more random. At times, pieces seem to dislodge and end up in a general area, which can make locating the piece you need more of a challenge.

PR​​​​OS

  • Ease of use
  • Full refund if dissatisfied

CONS

  • Quality of pieces
  • Design of carrying case

Users had mostly positive reviews of this product. The majority of drivers said this tire plug kit was easy to use. However, some of the negative feedback indicated the quality of parts seemed to be subpar compared to other tire plug kits on the market.

QUALITY

PRICE

OUR RATING

$$

5. Fix-a-Flat Aerosol Tire Inflator


We know you might not always want or need a complete tire plug kit. Unless you work or live near a construction site where nails are laying around, chances are you probably won’t puncture a tire that often. For those people, we included the Fix-a-Flat Aerosol Tire Inflator as the last item on our list.

This product is perfect for quick emergency repairs, assuming you intend to take your vehicle to a professional for a more comprehensive tire plug. The Fix-a-Flat Aerosol Tire Inflator works by simply spraying the puncture area and in just seconds this product forms a bond around the leaky around and even helps provide enough air pressure to lift your rim off the ground, so you can drive it a short distance to a repair shop. Plus, even though this is an aerosol product, Fix-a-Flat claims it is 100 percent environmentally friendly and will not contribute to global warming.

Customer reviews on this product were mixed. People either seemed to love it or hate it. Those that enjoyed the Fix-a-Flat Aerosol Tire Inflator were impressed at how effective it was as an emergency solution. However, there were a few reviews that claimed it did not perform a complete seal or only lasted a few miles.

PR​​​​OS

  • Ease of use during emergencies
  • Price 

CONS

  • Temporary solution
  • Inconsistent seal

Bottom line, this is an effective solution if you are looking for a cheap emergency repair but should not be counted on as a more long-term fix.

QUALITY

PRICE

OUR RATING

$$


Tire Plug Kit Buyer’s Guide


When deciding which tire plug kit is right for you, consider where you will be driving.

If you know you will be traveling on rough roads or streets with debris, you might want to invest in one of the more professional style kits because it’s likely you will need to fix a puncture. However, if you generally drive on smooth roads, you may not need a kit that has as many pieces or features, because you might never need it.

Just remember, in most of these kits, the fixes are just temporary. Do not assume that your tires are good as new. Even with the most expensive kit, you will likely need to have your tire fixed by a professional. It’s up to you to determine which product will tie you over until you can get your car into the shop.

Safety first.

The following two tabs change content below.
allen@incomestore.com'
  • Share On Facebook
  • Share On Twitter
  • Pin it!
  • Share On Facebook
  • Share On Twitter
  • Pin it!

mashoidadmin

allen@incomestore.com'
  • Share On Facebook
  • Share On Twitter
  • Pin it!
  • Share On Facebook
  • Share On Twitter
  • Pin it!

Latest posts by mashoidadmin (see all)

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This